Ian Knot History
Here's a run-down of the various things I've done with the Ian Knot since inventing it some thirty-seven years ago, culminating in the website you see today.
30-Jun-1982: The birth of the “Ian Knot”
One morning, after breaking yet another shoelace, I noticed that it always seemed to be the right end of my lace that broke. Because the regular method of tying shoelaces is not symmetrical, I figured that the end that experiences the most movement simply wears out more quickly.
When I examined the knot and found that it could be made symmetrical, I discovered quite by accident that the resultant technique was also much faster, as a lot of time was saved by working with both hands simultaneously.
Having mastered the new technique myself, I then set about teaching anyone else who was interested. I guess I'm one of the
few people who can claim to have taught their
parents to tie their shoelaces! Mostly, it was shown to friends and relatives and the occasional shoe-shop assistant.
01-Nov-1992: Created an instruction sheet
After a decade of teaching the “Ian Knot” to countless people in person, I finally decided to make a set of printed instructions that people could take home and study at leisure or copy and pass on to others. I drew illustrations of the six steps required, both “hands-on” and diagrammatically, accompanied by detailed step-by-step instructions.
Over the next few months I handed these out to many people. With their feedback, I gradually fine-tuned the diagrams and
instructions until the final draft in May-1993. I then had 1,000 copies printed – this turned out to be more than I would
hand out in a lifetime!
27-Jul-1993: Created a computer animation
This was still in the days before most people had software like "Windows" on their computers, making it difficult for them to view a simple video. I therefore captured 32 frames from a video of my “Ian Knot”, then wrote a tiny yet powerful MS-DOS program to display the resultant animation, complete with nine speed settings plus controls to step backwards or forwards one frame at a time. In fact, it turned out to be quite a good way to demonstrate the “Ian Knot”.
The resulting program was uploaded to various computer bulletin boards around the world, as we did in those days before the
Internet made such things easy.
01-Feb-1994: Optimized the Ian Knot animation
In order to make it smaller and more attractive to download, I compressed the video data by creating a static background
image of the underlying shoe, then painstakingly erasing the background data from each frame of the animation, leaving only
the fingers, laces and shadows. The resultant file was over 40% smaller – quite an achievement.
23-Apr-2000: Created a web page
This was still the early days of the Internet and geeks like me were only just beginning to put stuff online. I took my
original drawings from 1992, colored them in for a fresher look, and created my first
“Ian Knot” web page. This was uploaded to my personal website and thus made available to the world via the Internet.
25-Apr-2000: Added video to website
Some new video editing software enabled me to create a decent MPG video complete with sound track and subtitles. This
one-minute-long video showed the
“Ian Knot” at normal speed and in detail as well as the two other most common shoelace knots for comparison.
NOTE: This video was on the internet five years before YouTube even existed!
31-May-2001: Separate, shorter videos
With slow, dial-up modems still the predominant mode of connecting to the Internet, my original 9Mb video was too big for
many people to download. I therefore created three separate movies – one detailing the
“Ian Knot” (only 1.2Mb), with the other two (0.5Mb and 0.6Mb) showing each of the other common techniques. These
were faster and easier to download and also had larger, clearer subtitles.
NOTE: Five years later, this video started appearing on YouTube due to other people uploading it (without my permission!)
05-Jun-2001: Changed to overhead diagrams
Following a suggestion from a website visitor, I re-drew the
“Ian Knot” diagrams to show the shoes viewed from the same overhead perspective as the videos, which more closely
represents how a person would see their own shoes while tying them.
09-Feb-2003: Created Ian's Shoelace Site
The 20th anniversary of the
“Ian Knot” in 2002 plus an article about shoelaces in "Nature" magazine provided the impetus to expand my single
“Ian Knot” page into a multi-paged
“Ian's Shoelace Site”. This allowed me to begin adding more comprehensive instructions on other known shoelace knots,
which in turn sparked the expansion into other aspects of shoelaces.
2003 onwards: Added many more videos
Advances in visitors' computer capabilities, steadily falling bandwidth costs plus the 2005 launch of YouTube have allowed
me to gradually release
more videos covering different aspects of the
“Ian Knot”. Everything from a brief,
five-second-long demonstration to a detailed,
five-minute-long tutorial, even a
Future of the Ian Knot
As we approach the 37th anniversary of the “Ian Knot”, I'm saddened to discover that millions of people don't seem to know that I created this knot – or even that the knot has a name. I named it the “Ian Knot” not because I'm particularly egotistical but because I figured that “Ian” was easy to remember and spell. Alas, many reposts of my knot don't even give credit.
For example, searching YouTube in May-2017, I found over 400 videos titled "fast shoelace knot" or "tie shoes fast" or similar. Less than half of them even mentioned “Ian Knot”, while almost none of them linked to the source. Attribution doesn't seem to be common courtesy nowadays.
Worse, nearly half of those videos were inadvertently teaching the knot incorrectly, resulting in an un-secure Granny Knot, which sits crooked and comes undone. This is giving the “Ian Knot” an undeserved reputation as being fast at the expense of being unreliable – which is simply not true!
I hope that people are able to verify for themselves the true history of this knot, learn how to tie it correctly and securely, and have the courtesy to use my original title when sharing it with others. The future of the “Ian Knot” is in your hands.