Excess Shoelace Length
Many shoes nowadays come with shoelaces that are excessively long. Here's some theories about this phenomenon, as well as some practical solutions as to what to do about it.
Why The Excess Length?
The most likely reason for the excessive shoelace length is that manufacturers select from a smaller range of "stock lengths" rather than tailoring the length to each new shoe style.
For example, suppose a new sneaker design requires an ideal shoelace length of 47 inches. The manufacturers could supply either:
- Tailored length 47 inch laces (which are costly to produce);
- Stock length 45 inch laces (which may be slightly short);
- Stock length 54 inch laces (the next size longer).
It's also possible that manufacturers choose just one stock shoelace length to suit any new shoe model, even though each model comes in several fitting sizes. If the length was calculated to suit the largest fitting size for that model (eg. size 20), then everyone, regardless of their fitting size, would receive shoelaces suited to that largest shoe size.
What To Do About It
Shoelaces that are way too long can be a real nuisance. They require a lot of additional effort each time the laces are tied in order to take up all of the excess length so that the ends don't drag on the ground or get underfoot. Here's several possible solutions:
Excess Length Solutions
Some people wrap shoelaces around the ankle, particularly on tall hiking boots or skates. Wrapping several times may also increase ankle support, though at the risk of compression injury to the muscles or tendons.
Many people resort to tying a bulkier shoelace knot that consumes more shoelace, such as the Double Knot or the Double Ian Knot. This only shortens a limited amount, plus the knots are much more difficult to untie.
The excess length can instead be cut from the middle of the shoelace, then the two halves tied together with a joining knot such as a Reef Knot. Using two different colored laces creates a bi-colored lace suitable for Half & Half Lacing.
One simple alternative is to use a different lacing method that consumes more shoelace. For example, Spider Web Lacing effectively "shortens" lace ends by about 11%.
Replacing the shoelaces with the correct length is the best alternative. While you're at it, choose a different material, color or pattern to better suit your individual preference.